By Canadian Press

Pulling ads from Facebook could force its hand on news deals — if support grows

Jul 6, 2023 | 12:13 PM

MONTREAL — Pulling ads from Facebook could prod Meta toward inking deals with news outlets, though more momentum would be needed to push it over the edge, experts say.

The tactic adopted by several governments and companies in Canada this week might force the social media giant’s hand if other countries and corporations follow suit in larger markets, said Sam Andrey, managing director of the Dais at Toronto Metropolitan University.

“I thought it was interesting how quickly a bunch of organizations and governments followed, and I’m sure there will be more,” he said.

“The government of Canada by itself as an advertiser is not a huge material loss for them in the scheme of their total Canadian advertising. But if it kicks off a movement then you could see them reconsidering.”

The federal government — followed swiftly by the province of Quebec, the City of Montreal and media companies Quebecor Inc. and Cogeco Inc. — said yesterday they would suspend advertising on Facebook and Instagram as tensions with tech titans rise over the Online News Act.

new mayor

Spring Mayoral by-election called in Ladysmith

8h ago

holiday check stops

Nanaimo motorists shine during province-wide crackdown

11h ago

targeted job action

Striking Nanaimo postal workers disrupt Purolator operations

14h ago

Bill C-18, passed in June but not set to take effect until late December, forces digital giants to pay media outlets for content they share or repurpose on their platforms.

In response, Meta and Google announced last month they would remove news by Canadian journalism outlets from their sites before the law comes into force.

Kent Walker, president of global affairs for Google and its parent company Alphabet, said in an interview last week the law is unworkable because it puts a price on links, resulting in an uncapped financial liability “that no business could accept.”

“I think we need clear financial expectations, and we need a clear and realistic path toward exemption that takes into account our commercial agreements and the other support we provide for news in Canada,” Walker said.

A spokesperson for Meta said the regulatory process won’t be able to address the changes the company wants to see, which is why it plans to remove news from its platforms. 

“Unfortunately, the regulatory process is not equipped to make changes to the fundamental features of the legislation that have always been problematic, and so we plan to comply by ending news availability in Canada in the coming weeks,” they said on Wednesday. 

The $10 million a year that Canada’s heritage minister said it spends on advertising with Facebook and Instagram amounts to a tiny fraction of Meta’s US$113 billion in ad revenue last year.

Nonetheless, media watchers say Meta may have to reconsider its strategy if larger companies as well as governments that are crafting similar legislation — including the United States, United Kingdom and Brazil — follow Canada’s lead.

“Other democratic countries such as United States, Mexico, the EU could all take some similar principled steps,” said Courtney Radsch, director of Center for Journalism and Liberty, a Washington, D.C.-based think tank.

The six-month period before the bill comes into effect gives Ottawa time to decide how to proceed with regulations. But a spokesperson for Meta said fine tuning won’t be able to address the core changes the company wants to see.

“Unfortunately, the regulatory process is not equipped to make changes to the fundamental features of the legislation that have always been problematic, and so we plan to comply by ending news availability in Canada in the coming weeks,” the spokesperson said in a statement Wednesday.

When Australia introduced a similar law in 2021, Meta temporarily blocked news from Facebook. In that country, Meta and Google entered into agreements with news publishers, as Bill C-18 also requires.

Now, Meta may be using Canada as a cautionary tale to other countries, Andrey suggested.

“They are worried about this spreading from Australia — and now to Canada — to much larger jurisdictions,” he said.

“We just have the unfortunate position of being a test case for them. If they can make it hurt here, will others not want to follow? It’s bullying tactics.”

Meta has said pulling news links simply puts it in line with the law.

Beyond dollars and cents, reputations are also at stake.

“I think there’s real risk for Meta,” Andrey continued.

“There’s already concern about the spread of disinformation and conspiracy theories. If you remove authoritative news sources, do you feed that perception that the information on these platforms isn’t credible?”

Whether social media users care is another matter. A handful of Canadian governments and telecoms yanking ads may not grab the attention of teens on Instagram. But if larger, hipper retail brands or celebrities chimed in, and especially if the user experience were altered, the tide could start to turn.

CBC News’s editor-in-chief, Brodie Fenlon, released an article this week describing how he was unable to see posts on the brand’s Instagram page, which had a note saying the content was blocked “in response to Canadian government legislation.”

“Once those roll out, people will care about that, because it’s adding friction to their internet experience,” Andrey said.

—With files from Tara Deschamps in Toronto and Mickey Djuric in Ottawa

This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 6, 2023.

Companies in this story: (TSX:QBR.B, TSX:CGO)

———

Meta funds a limited number of fellowships that support emerging journalists at The Canadian Press.

Christopher Reynolds, The Canadian Press